Reading Romantasy as a Man

Guest essay — by an anonymous contributor

Okay, let me tell you about the time I got absolutely WRECKED by a fantasy romance novel on a plane.

I was on a long flight. I’d burned through my thriller. My partner had slipped her copy of A Court of Mist and Fury into my bag with a sticky note that just said: “Just try it.” And look — I was skeptical in that very specific way dudes who haven’t read the genre are skeptical. Not hostile. Just carrying this vague, culturally inherited certainty that this wasn’t For Me. That I’d feel like a trespasser flipping through pages meant for someone else entirely.

I finished the book before we landed. Bought the sequel in the airport terminal before I even grabbed my luggage.

And I haven’t shut up about it since. Because what romantasy offers male readers isn’t just “surprisingly good.” It’s something I genuinely cannot find anywhere else in fiction. And the assumption that it’s not for us? That’s not just wrong — it’s actively robbing you of some of the best reading experiences available right now.

The “This Isn’t For Me” Lie

Let’s be real: romantasy is marketed to women. The covers scream it. The BookTok community driving its massive sales is predominantly female. The emotional register — the deep interiority, the relentless focus on relationships, the explicit and UNAPOLOGETIC attention to desire — is coded feminine in ways our culture still treats as a “keep out” sign for male readers.

Here’s the thing though: the genre is doing perfectly fine without male validation. It’s DOMINATING publishing. This isn’t a loss for romantasy. It’s a loss for the men who are stubbornly missing out.

Because what I found in ACOTAR — and in every sprawling romantasy epic I’ve devoured since — is a kind of devastating emotional honesty about desire and vulnerability that male-coded fiction almost NEVER offers. Traditional male-oriented fantasy treats the outer world as the battlefield. Armies clash, kings fall, magic systems break. Romantasy takes feelings with lethal seriousness. It treats your inner life as the primary site of drama. It’s interested in what it FEELS like to want something and be absolutely terrified of wanting it.

That’s not a female experience. That’s a human experience. And men are rarely given permission to explore it in the fiction we’re told is “for us.”

What Morally Grey Love Interests Actually Offer Men

I need to talk about Rhysand for a second, and this might be controversial in male reading circles: he is one of the most USEFUL male characters I’ve encountered in fiction. Specifically because of how he navigates the terrifying intersection of power and vulnerability.

Rhysand is powerful — genuinely, world-breakingly powerful. He’s also in a position of agonizing emotional vulnerability he can’t fully control. He loves Feyre in a way that actively COSTS him. He makes brutal choices that prioritize her psychological wellbeing over his own pride, safety, and fearsome reputation. He is, in the most literal sense, undone by love — and the series treats this not as weakness but as the single most heroic thing about him.

Male fiction almost never does this. Male characters in action and high fantasy are allowed to love, sure — but the love is always subordinate to the plot. It motivates them, gives them something to protect, occasionally gets fridged so they have something to avenge. It’s almost never the primary site of their transformation. In romantasy, the love interest’s devotion IS the transformation. The politics, the war, the magic — that’s all set dressing for the central emotional reality.

Reading this as a man is strange, jarring, and ultimately clarifying. It offers a model of masculinity that is lethally capable AND emotionally present — one that doesn’t treat vulnerability as incompatible with strength. I didn’t expect to find that in a fantasy romance novel. But I found it nowhere else.

The Female Gaze Will Rearrange Your Brain

Romantasy is written from the female gaze. The male love interests are described through the eyes of women who desire them — and the descriptions are detailed, physical, and wonderfully unapologetic. Shoulders. Jawlines. Hands. The specific cadence of a voice. The text LINGERS on male bodies in a way that completely flips the traditional literary script.

Reading this as a man is a wild experience of psychological displacement. You’re not the subject of the gaze anymore. You’re reading from the position of someone who desires rather than someone who’s accustomed to being the default desiring subject of every narrative ever written.

I found this unexpectedly valuable. The male gaze in fiction is SO pervasive, so baked into the water we swim in, that I’d never noticed it as a “gaze” at all. Reading from the opposite position made the invisible visible. It made me aware of how much fiction I’d consumed that was written specifically for me to identify with the desiring subject rather than the desired object. Romantasy inverts that completely. And honestly? It’s profoundly educational. It teaches you how women actually experience desire — divorced from the performative nonsense of patriarchal media.

The Freedom to Actually Feel Things

There’s a specific exhaustion that comes from consuming media where emotion is treated as a liability. In so many stories aimed at men, feelings are something to conquer, push aside for the mission, or express only through the acceptable conduits of righteous anger or stoic grief. It’s EXHAUSTING.

Romantasy is an absolute sanctuary from that emotional austerity. It’s a genre where feeling things so deeply it breaks the world is not only acceptable — it’s the POINT. It understands that the most terrifying battlefield is often just a quiet room containing two people who are desperately afraid to admit they need each other.

Your Assignment: Write the Inverted Gaze

If you’re a male reader or a writer trying to capture the romantasy aesthetic, you NEED to learn to navigate the female gaze and the prioritization of internal emotional stakes. So here’s your homework:

The Constraint: Write a 300-word scene from a female protagonist’s perspective, observing a male character doing something entirely mundane — sharpening a blade, reading a map, repairing armor. Describe him entirely through the female gaze. Focus not on brute strength or utility, but on micro-expressions, the vulnerability in his posture, the specific physical details that betray his internal emotional state. Make the mundane crackle with unacknowledged desire.

Drop your scenes in the comments. Let’s dissect how the gaze shifts narrative weight.

Where to Start (Actual Recs, No Judgment)

If you’re a guy reading this and thinking “okay, fine, where do I actually begin?” — here are five entry points organized by what you already read:

• If you read epic fantasy: A Court of Mist and Fury — skip book one if you must, start at ACOMAF. The political complexity and power dynamics are genuinely interesting.
• If you read grimdark: The Cruel Prince by Holly Black — it’s ruthless, political, and the romance is built on genuine adversarial tension.
• If you read sci-fi/urban fantasy: Crescent City by Sarah J. Maas — modern setting, murder mystery structure, the romance is a slow-building subplot.
• If you read literary fiction: Spinning Silver by Naomi Novik — folklore, economics, and a romance built on intellectual sparring.
• If you just want the best one: The best romantasy list — sorted by subgenre so you can pick what suits your taste.

Read them with the same critical eye you bring to any fiction. The genre rewards close reading.

What I Wish Someone Had Told Me

If I could go back and talk to myself before that flight, here’s what I’d say: the genre is NOT about romance in the sanitized Hallmark way you think “romance” means. It’s about desire in the absolute broadest sense — desire for love, yes, but also for power, for belonging, for a self that is fully, dangerously realized. It’s about what it COSTS to want things, and what it means to actually get them.

Also? The action sequences are better choreographed than most epic fantasy. The world-building is more emotionally resonant than most literary fiction. And it’s frequently very funny.

But mostly: it will give you access to an interior life that male fiction has been quietly withholding from you. Not because it was written for you — it wasn’t — but because good fiction is ALWAYS bigger than its intended audience. The best romantasy isn’t “women’s fiction.” It’s fiction about being human, written from a perspective men rarely give themselves permission to inhabit.

That’s worth the price of admission. That’s worth infinitely MORE than the price of admission. Trust me on this one.

Keep reading: Review: ACOTAR · Morally Grey Love Interest Fantasy Books · Why Romantic Fantasy Owns Our Hearts

External resource: The Guardian: Fantasy Books

📚 Recommended reads mentioned in this essay:

• Start with A Court of Thorns and Roses →
• Pick up Fourth Wing →

Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.

You might also enjoy: post_name . />The Physics of Bookish Desire: Why I Buy the Same Book Three Times